Home Icon

How to choose accounting software

By Nathan Taylor | 7:23 am 21/12/2012

There’s no question that a good accounting software package can revolutionise the way businesses large and small can work. Depending on the package, accounting software can automatically generate and send invoices, create quotes, manage inventory, calculate employee payroll and superannuation, submit BAS statements electronically and interface with the ATO’s online tools. They can also provide business performance feedback, tracks jobs and expenses and much more.

At the personal level, accounting software can also make your annual tax submissions much easier, it can track stocks and investments, manage household budgets and inventory, automate payment of bills and even track the amount of carbon you’re using.

But which one is right for you? For most small business, switching accounting and invoicing systems is a big deal, so you want to get it right.

Accounting software is tiered

There are two major providers of accounting software in Australia: MYOB and Reckon (which releases Australian versions of Intuit’s Quicken and QuickBooks). Both provide solutions for small, medium and large businesses as well as sole traders. Reckon also provides personal accounting software, under the Quicken name.

Quicken Personal is the basic package. It covers banking and bills, home budgeting and annual taxes. Quicken Personal Plus adds investments and stock tracking, home inventory management, carbon management, superannuation and more.

Basic accounting packages help you to keep track of domestic bills and budgets.

When it comes to business accounting (even if the business is a sole trader), the software from both MYOB and Reckon is tiered. That is to say, each tier contains nearly all the features (represented by ticks in the table below) of the tiers below it, plus some significant additional features. The key to choosing the right accounting software is to work out how far up the chain you should go. At the bottom rung, the software typically costs less than $300, with packages aimed at larger enterprises going up to nearly $2000.

Those chains are rough mirrors of each other: QuickBooks Accounting is roughly equivalent to MYOB AccountRight Standard, for example. The choice between them often comes to price, personal interface preferences and support for some finer details needed by a specific business.

Both vendors also have several products that don’t fit neatly into that chain. Quicken is for personal finances, for example, and MYOB has Just Invoices, which is for people who aren’t interested in the accounting elements and just want a system for generating and tracking invoices.

The steps after this will be a guide to let you know how far up the chain you should go.

Tier one: Sole trader or very small business

The solutions to look for here are: MYOB Just Invoices, MYOB AccountRight Basics, QuickBooks EasyStart and QuickBooks EasyStart Lite.

MYOB Just Invoices does what it says in the title: it creates and tracks invoices. MYOB AccountRight Basics and QuickBooks EasyStart add GST calculation and submission, job tracking, expense management and other things that a small one or two person operation requires. (EasyStart Lite is similar to EasyStart, but has a strict limit on the number of clients/customers supported).

Tier two: Small retail business

At this tier, we’re looking at MYOB AccountRight Standard and QuickBooks Accounting. The big additions here are inventory and supplier management. These features allow you to keep track of what you have in stock, largely automate the ordering of new stock and keep track of all suppliers

MYOB and Reckon have an additional product in this space called RetailManager and QuickBooks Retail Point of Sale (respectively), that support fast sale processing, laybys, customer contacts and promotion and more. They’re not really a replacement for the accounting packages, however – they don’t support many accounting features. Instead they work with the accounting software.

Tier three: Small business with employees

QuickBooks Plus and MYOB AccountRight Plus add payroll management to the suite of tools included in the above tiers. This includes employee record tracking, PAYG calculation and submission, superannuation contributions and more.

Accounting software can mean you no longer have to wade through mountains of Excel spreadsheets.

Tier four: Larger business

MYOB AccountRight Premier, QuickBooks Pro and QuickBooks Premier take the features of the previous tiers and up their scale to be suitable for a business with a larger employee and customer base. They have more advanced inventory tracking, employee tracking systems, business performance graphing and data mining, industry-specific elements, batch processing of forms and invoices and more. They also support multiple users and multiple currencies.

Comparison of small and medium business accounting software

Try before you buy!

If you’re still not sure which solution is exactly right for you, then you can certainly try out the software before splashing down the full price. For less than $10, Officeworks sells the MYOB Test Drive CD and QuickBooks Trial DVD. These DVD have full working versions of the various products with a three-month license. This way you can look through the different tiers yourself and find out which one has the right features for your business.

Try before you buy with sample versions of MYOB and Quicken accounting packages.






Latest reviews

  • Review: Leica Q (Typ 116)

    Not all cameras are the same, and Leica’s Q proves it, packing a full-frame 35mm sensor, 28mm f/1.7 fixed lens, and a body that says “camera” more than most…
  • Review: KEF M200 in-earphones

    If there’s one thing KEF understands, it’s audio, with the company producing some of the best speakers we’ve ever heard. Unfortunately, we can’t carry big speakers everywhere we go,…
  • Review: Jawbone Up 2

    Need a bit of help getting in shape? Jawbone hopes to have the answer in an update to its Up 24, with the new sequel, the slimmer Up 2.
  • Review: Samsung Gear VR for Galaxy S6/S6 Edge

    With the upcoming releases of the consumer-ready Oculus Rift and HTC’s Vive, virtual reality is about ready for use by regular people. Samsung is there now, though, and…
  • Oppo's 4.85mm thin R5 smartphone reviewed

    Apple may lead the smartphone wars with the iPhone, but Oppo is challenging the big A for some inventiveness, finding a way to make mobiles slimmer than ever with…
  • Review: LifeProof FRE Power for iPhone 6 (battery case)

    Smartphone batteries tend not to go for longer than a day, and Apple’s iPhone 6 is no exception, but the latest case from accessory maker LifeProof isn’t just about…
  • Review: Beats Solo 2 Wireless headphones

    Beats has one of those interesting reputations. Kids and young people love ‘em, while the older generation can’t stand them, but the latest pair tries to win over all…
  • Review: Toshiba Satellite Radius L10W

    Smaller computers are ideal for students and people on the go, and when they’re also technically tablets, they can be even better. Is Toshiba’s Radius L10W a hybrid worthy…
  • Review: LG 65 inch Prime 4K UHD TV

    It's not enough to have a big screen, and this year LG's 4K TVs are about more colours, fast operation, and sharp visuals. Does it succeed?
  • Review: HP Spectre X360

    HP's Spectre was one of the surprise laptops from last year, and a return for HP to the quality laptop space. Can the latest generation of Spectre keep the…

“How do you stop yourself from being caught out by these scam artists?”

Read More

Tell us…

Which smartwatch are you interested in buying?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

“There’s certainly no doubt that you can find a bargain, but like always, you get what you pay for.”

Read More