Home Icon
htc-one-screen

Retina reviewed: which smartphone screen rates best

By Leigh D. Stark | 5:48 pm 02/05/2013

Ever since Apple decided that mobile phone screens should be sharper when it introduced the “Retina” display concept, mobile manufacturers have been working hard to improve this idea considerably.

When Apple launched the iPhone 4, the screen displayed more resolution in a small space than had been seen on a phone up to that point.

The pixel per inch count was 329ppi on a 3.5 inch display, and when the iPhone 5 rolled around, it dropped marginally to 326ppi, thanks to the extra half inch Apple added to its design.

Apple called this concept “Retina” because it was sharper and better for the eyes, and it totally changed the way smartphone screens were looked at.

But this year – in 2013 – everything is different. Manufacturers aren’t just trying to match Apple’s Retina technology like they were last year when 720p HD screens were trotted out. No, this year manufacturers are attempting to beat it altogether, improving displays to such a level we’ve never seen.

Numbers that go past Apple’s 326 pixels per inch are on offer, as companies throw Full HD panels into smartphones.

All of this results in a level of definition that has to be seen to be believed. It’s like looking at a light-up paper printout – better even – and the quality and clarity available from handsets this year is so impressive, you’ll wonder how you even lived without it.

These screens are so sharp, they go beyond the level that the average human eye can see, can discern the difference between.

To show where we’re coming from with this, Wikipedia suggests that most people can’t work out the difference once you go beyond 300 pixels per inch, a statement by Steve Jobs that has been argued. Regardless of which side you sit on, we’ll always end up being the bottleneck since our eyes are only capable of so much. For many people out there, 300ppi screens will be completely fine, but there are higher quality screens coming out regardless.

Up until this article was published, every flagship phone on the market we looked at featured pixel per inch counts above 300, and with the benchmark from Apple set at 326 in the iPhone 5, we wanted to see what the competition looked like, so we’ve taken out a digital microscope to check it out.

Now it’s worth pointing out that every screen is different and uses individual technologies, but up close, what we’re looking for is the way text looks, which seems to be one of the better tests. When letters feature strong anti-aliasing and you can see the flow of letters as they curve out among the pixels, that’s where you can see the quality of the screen and how many pixels it’s packing in.

More pixels mean the letters look better and clearer from far away, and when a phone is held at arm’s length from your eyes, that distance and those pixels can mean all the different from being able to read tiny text and being forced to zoom in.

We’ve made things a little fun, too, and with our interactive examples in this article, you’ll be able to drag the line in the middle of the frame to see what the pixels look like in between. All tests were made running Google’s Chrome and we’ve done our best to align the examples, but it can be difficult, so forgive us if it doesn’t work perfectly.

At the Retina-class end of the spectrum, we have Apple’s iPhone 5 with 326ppi, as well as the LG Optimus G which features 318ppi.

LG and Apple look closely tied on this one, with similar qualities on each. Neither of them are any match for the Full HD screens of the Sony Xperia Z, HTC One, and Samsung Galaxy S4 though.

While the text quality looks pretty close in both the Sony Xperia Z (left) and the Samsung Galaxy S4 (right), it’s the screen types that show up here, with different types of pixels. Both are very clear from far back, and with both displays packing in 441 pixels per inch, it’s not a surprise. Up close close, though, we think Sony has the edge.

But the Xperia Z doesn’t have the biggest amount of pixels available right now. No, that goes to HTC and it’s new “One.” So which of these will win against each other?

With the Sony on the left and the HTC on the right, we’re inclined to think it’s a draw. There isn’t a whole lot of difference between 441 and 468 pixels per inch, and we’re already well beyond what most people’s eyes will be able to discern.

From our point of view, both of these screens are top notch, with the HTC One better marginally, though there’s a lot more to a phone than just its screen.

We’re not completely done though, because we’ve seen two phablets this year. While the Samsung Galaxy Note 2 and Huawei Ascend Mate are completely different phablets with completely different price tags, their resolutions are the same. That said, the screens are completely different thanks to the overall dimensions.

From what we’re seeing here, the Samsung Galaxy Note 2 (left) stomps all over the Huawei Ascend Mate (right) in resolution quality, though that doesn’t surprise us. That said, because the screens are larger, the text will appear bigger regardless, and you won’t need to pull the phones closer to your eyes.

UPDATE (May 6, 2013):
We’ve added another frame of the Samsung Galaxy S4′s 441ppi screen against the HTC One’s 468ppi so you can see what the differences are, but the images don’t align as well as we’d hoped. It does work, but the HTC image needs more straightening.

However, we should point out that the dividers in between the examples can be moved by you, so you can slide the divider back and forth and see the pixels!

Latest reviews

  • Review: HP ElitePad 1000 G2

    When you talk about business grade tablets, there aren't a lot of choices, but HP's ElitePad 1000 G2 looks to provide a dose of shiny silver aluminium professionalism to…
  • Apple's iPhone 6 Plus reviewed

    Apple has steered clear of tablet-sized phones for a while now, leaving it to Samsung and other manufacturers, but now Apple is here with a phablet of its own.…
  • Review: LG G Pad 10.1

    LG's G3 really grabbed our attention earlier in the year, so we're expecting good things from a tablet launched around the same time, but is the G Pad 10.1…
  • Review: Plantronics BackBeat Pro headphones

    Headphones that cut out the noise from the outside world generally require you to be tethered to your phone, but not a new pair of cans from Plantronics, as…
  • Review: Moto G (2014, G2)

    Big phones are in, and to go with that trend, Motorola is upgrading one of its entry-level handsets, increasing the screen size of its G series phone to make…
  • Review: Acer Aspire Switch 10

    Acer's 10 inch Windows tablet hasn't been updated since Windows 8 first came out, and that was two years ago, so what has Acer been cooking up, and does…
  • Review: Dyson Cool (AM06)

    Here come the warmer months and that reason to get the old trusty fan out. But before you do, you might want to consider a healthy update of the…
  • You little beauty: Sony’s Xperia Z3 Compact reviewed

    Smartphones may well be getting bigger, but Sony’s Xperia Z3 Compact aims to show people that a smartphone doesn’t need to be big to be powerful, boasting high-end specs…
  • Review: Bose QuietComfort 25i (QC25/QC25i)

    If there's one company that tends to do well in the field of noise cancellation, it's Bose. We've seen its headphones used by so many on overseas trips, and…
  • Review: Oppo N1 Mini

    Do you like selfies but are sick of the one or two megapixel cameras smartphones are coming with? Oppo's answer to this is an interesting one, putting the 13…

“How do you stop yourself from being caught out by these scam artists?”

Read More

Tell us…

Which smartwatch are you interested in buying?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

“There’s certainly no doubt that you can find a bargain, but like always, you get what you pay for.”

Read More