Now that Apple has released the iPad 2 and Samsung is getting the Galaxy Tab 10.1v ready for a mid-April time-frame, we’ve decided to pit the two against each other to see what comes out on top.
If there’s one thing we know about Apple, it’s that they’re usually ahead of the game when it comes to design. We can’t recall a single Apple product that didn’t feel like it was designed well, even if it wasn’t the best product in its class.
The iPad 2 follows this with a very sexy metal aluminium and glass enclosure that feels fantastic in the hands. At 601 grams and 8.8mm thick, it’s light in the hands despite feeling like an oversized matt-finish iPod Touch.
One new design aspect that we liked was the inclusion of magnets on the left-side that allowed the iPad Smart Cover (an optional cost of at least $45) to snap on with no fuss.
Samsung’s Galaxy Tab 10.1v is very different from the iPad 2, using plastic and glass instead of a better quality material like aluminium. The Tab doesn’t feel cheap by any standard, but it doesn’t ooze the cool sturdy feeling you get from picking up an iPad 2. It’s also a little thicker at 10.9mm, but just two grams lighter (599g).
The Galaxy Tab 10.1v is nice, but it just doesn’t have the feel that Apple has with the iPad 2, so it wins this one.
Winner: Apple iPad 2
We’re in a new generation here, and as such, every tablet needs to use a very fast processor. With the iPad 2 and Galaxy Tab 10.1v, we’re in luck, as each unit uses a dual-core processor capable of super-fast processing with some level of dedicated graphics.
They all have WiFi (up to the “n” standard), Bluetooth, and 3G (except for the WiFi only iPad 2 models).
Screen-wise, both models occupy nearly the same space, with the Galaxy Tab 10.1v offering a 1280×800 16:9 screen 10.1-inch screen, while the iPad 2 offers a lower resolution 1024×768 4:3 screen 9.7-inch screen. Out of these, the Samsung is the only one to feature an HD-ready screen, supporting at least 1280×720 HD.
New to the iPad 2 is front and rear camera, but sadly, they’re not very good cameras at all. On the rear, Apple has gone with a 1280×720 HD camera, while the front gets only a VGA 640×480 camera. Both of these are below the 2 megapixel camera found on the original iPhone from 2007, and are well below the 8 megapixel (with flash) rear camera and 2 megapixel front camera found on the Galaxy Tab 10.1v.
For the operating system, the iPad 2 has the same iOS you’ve grown to love if you’ve had an iPad or iPhone. As for the Galaxy Tab 10.1v, Samsung is using Google’s Android Honeycomb, a version of Android made for tablets. It’s a little different than what’s found on phones, but still includes the multiple widget screens and Google network integration.
Then there’s the ecosystem, as both Google and Apple offer an assortment of applications to purchase and download. Apple’s offering is larger, covering movies, music, and books, but Google’s is growing, with a music system likely to be added within months.
Judging this was a hard one, because as much as we love the Apple ecosystem – iTunes, thousands of apps, iBooks, etc – the iPad 2 isn’t a huge upgrade on where it was last year in the original iPad. Given the low quality of cameras on the iPad 2, all that’s really changed is more graphics and processing power, a different design, and some magnets for use with the iPad Smart Cover system. If you’ve already got a first-generation iPad, there’s not much that really warrants the purchase of a new device.
With a fast dual-core processor, some great cameras, support for Flash, and Google’s own ecosystem, we’re giving Samsung the win this round.
Winner: Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1
It’s hard to judge performance of a tablet without real benchmarks that can be shared across platform to platform, but what we can see so far is that both work well.
The Galaxy Tab 10.1v turns out to be a nice piece of kit, with little to no speed lost between applications, browsing web pages, and playing media. Even the battery held strong, as we managed to get a little under two days as we used 3G, WiFi, and watched the occasional video.
As you can expect, the iPad 2 has been tuned to Apple’s high expectations, and it performs admirably. The screen is very responsive, applications and games appear to run faster, and the battery life sits at between one and two days of usage.
When it comes to purchasing an iPad 2, you’ve got a little bit more choice than what Samsung has with the Galaxy Tab 10.1v.
Currently, Apple has 6 options spread out between $579 and $949.
On the other hand, if you want the Galaxy Tab 10.1v, you’ve just got a 16GB model with 3G, WiFi, and no memory expansion. Much like the 16GB 3G/WiFi iPad 2, this can be found for $729 or $259 upfront payment plus $39 per month over 12 months.
More options is better in our books, so Apple wins this round.
Winner: Apple iPad 2
The first thing you’ll probably get for your new tablet – regardless of who makes it – is some form of protection, and we’re betting that Apple will win here hands down.
While we’ve yet to confirm exactly what Samsung has in store for accessories, we have been told there will be an assortment of covers available, we just doubt it will come in the same numbers as the iPad 2.
Let’s face it, the iPad has this area numbered. You’ll find screen covers, skins, covers, cases, extra ports (such as Apple’s HDMI connector), and probably even some iPad docks similar to the one Bang & Olufsen released last year supporting both the iPhone and iPad.
Samsung’s Galaxy Tab 10.1v has gone with the proprietary connector we found on the 7 inch Galaxy Tab last year, but we’ve yet to see any released accessories in stores for that connection.
Winner: Apple iPad 2
When it comes to iPad competition, we know there’s a lot coming. We’ve mentioned a few in the past, but there’s tablets coming from Acer, Asus, BlackBerry, HP, LG, Motorola, Toshiba, and Viewsonic to name but a few.
We wouldn’t be surprised if Nokia dropped something by this year either.
That should tell you that tablets and slates are this year’s “hot product,” and anyone and everyone will be trying their hand at releasing one.
Right now, the Apple iPad 2 is probably the best tablet around, but that could change very quickly.
If there’s one thing that Samsung has shown us with the Galaxy Tab 10.1v, it’s that competitors can really bring something strong against the iPad. It’s true that the Galaxy Tab 10.1v is the first incarnation of Honeycomb we’ve seen and it still has bugs. That said, it’s still an excellent product, even with its bugs.
There are things this reviewer prefers in Android over Apple’s iOS, such as multiple widget screens, Flash compatibility, and a more open marketplace. And with loads more tablets on the way from various manufacturers – each likely to have their own unique features – the world of tablets can only get more interesting.