BYOx simply means
bring your own computing device but how
do you know what device is best? It is different
too for primary (P1-7), secondary (P8-12) and tertiary students.
There are lots of problems with BYOx
These mainly stem from the vast range of Windows and Mac laptops and Android and iPad tablets provided these have detachable keyboards as well.
This raises ‘equity’
issues. Will a child be at a disadvantage using a MacBook if the rest of the class
is using a Windows laptop or vice versa?
There is the issue of cost. We don’t want to create a digital
divide between those who can afford and those who cannot. Cost also extends to damage/repair and loss –
insurance does not always cover that. A social justice scheme is needed.
There is the software. Do we all settle on Microsoft Word/Excel,
Google Docs/Sheets or Apple iWork Pages/numbers? And can the recommended educational
software run on your device? What about lower-cost educational pricing too?
Finally has the school the expertise and infrastructure to handle all students using Wi-Fi and printers, let alone supporting so many computers? What about the risk of virus/malware or misuse?
The Queensland Government BYOx trial was enlightening
Government BYODx trial no doubt
repeated in many States explored all aspects of this change in pedagogy – from
leaning with a pen, paper and books, to learning
on glass! Are the teachers and the curriculum – maths, English, science, and
social studies ready to use computers instead of books to engage students?
The bottom line is schools really should not set the bar too
high and be able to cope with almost any Windows, Mac, Android or iPad as long
as it can connect to the internet. However, most schools set regulations for
approved devices, and some go as far as
to mandate only one type of device. Some may have a school or P&C
owned/rental programs in place.
So what does that all mean?
First, ask your school
for a copy of its BYOD or BYOx policy. Most state schools now have a compulsory
BYOx policy for year seven onwards
although from 2020 it will likely be year four onwards.
Most government schools recommend a Windows 10 laptop and have settled on Office 365 – Word and Excel as the productivity software.
BYOx specifications for 2019
HARDWARE MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS
Years 7 to
WINDOWS LAPTOP Windows 10 (NOT Windows 10S) 64-bit capable CPU (Intel Core i3/i5/i7 – 7th or 8th generation) or AMD Athlon A series Wi-Fi AC 2.4/5GHZ 4GB Ram (prefer 8) 128GB SSD – prefer 256GB and not HDD
MAC LAPTOP MAC OS Sierra or later Wi-Fi AC 2.4/5GHZ
ACCESSORIES – all Protective Case for your laptop – Consider a “ruggedised” case Mouse (wireless USB Chargeable or corded)
Accident Protection Insurance (with purchase or check your Home and Contents Insurance Policy) At home an SD card or external backup device
HARDWARE RECOMMENDED REQUIREMENTS – Graphics & Industrial Design, Visual Arts
to 12 Laptop
As above plus 8GB Ram 256GB or larger SSD Dedicated Video Card 2GB Memory or higher
Students can choose to bring another device type
You can use an iPad or Android tablet with a keyboard however differences in the way apps and websites look and function may mean they have compatibility issues. The school takes no responsibility for that.
Most also charge an annual fee for ‘infrastructure connection’
and charge for rental of academic software needed. This seems to range between $50 and $100.
If you can’t afford it,
schools must offer a laptop hire scheme via direct debit or Centrepay.
Smartphones and devices without keyboards are not allowed.
The right device is a tough
Kids often put you on a guilt trip wanting the best technology
and the highest price. Then they roughhouse it in their backpack and put stickers
all over it. Weight is also a consideration. Cheap
laptops are heavier!
GadgetGuy’s advice is that a cheap laptop won’t last so look
for rugged or MIL-SPEC rated. Good battery life – at least 6 hours of office use
– is mandatory because there are not many 240V power points in a classroom.
You don’t need much processing power to run Office etc. An Intel Core i3 or i5 or AMD Athlon 3000 is fine but 8GB+ of RAM and a 256GB+ SSD (solid state drive) will get you through years 7 to 12. Avoid older Celeron, Pentium or other AMD models.
Screen size – bigger is better
13 to 15” is most common and FHD (1920 x 1080) resolution is
best. Touch and the use of a stylus is nice
for things like drawing and annotation, but
it adds a couple of hundred dollars. Larger screens are often heavier.
The requirement for a dedicated video card with 2GB RAM or higher is to support programmes like Adobe Creative Suite. Frankly, Intel 7th or 8th Generation Core i5 and i7 processors will easily support this.
The best way to buy Office
365 is an annual Home subscription at $129 for up to six installations. Some
schools can supply a free version as well.
What is hot?
Acer, ASUS, Dell, HP and Lenovo dominate the Windows world. It is hard to go wrong with any of these brands.
Apple has the MacBook.
All have decent products in the $699-1000 range, so it’s a matter of getting the fastest processor, most ram, largest storage and biggest [touch] screen you can. Don’t be a brand snob.
In the $1000-2000 range,
you will start to see HP Pavilion and Envy, Lenovo Yoga, Microsoft Surface
Laptop and Pro (care – the keyboard costs extra), Dell Inspiron 5000, Apple
MacBook Air, ASUS Zenbook, Acer Spin 5 and Swift 3 (higher spec). Most apart
from Apple are touchscreens.
MIL-STD-810G like HP EliteBook and Spectre,
Lenovo Think Pad, Dell Lattitude start
over $2,000 and go to $4000.