Sign in with Microsoft
Review: Breville The Perfect Press sandwich toaster
4.4Overall Score

Price (RRP): $129
Manufacturer: Breville

A few days ago I mentioned Breville’s new The Perfect Press sandwich maker which, says Breville “revolutionises” the making of toasted sandwiches. Time, now, to apply margarine to bread, fillings to the interior, and put it to the test. The model number is BSG600BSS.

Features

To repeat, this is a two-sandwich flat press, not the traditional type of sandwich toaster which seals the edges of the sandwiches and cuts them across the middle. Breville’s claim is that by reducing the applied force via its “crush control” hinge mechanism – reducing the applied force from as much as two kilograms down to 425 grams – your sandwich contents won’t be squeezed out the sandwich’s sides, nor the whole thing flattened. Instead it says that your sandwich will remain “light and fluffy on the inside”.

It also offers an “open melt” position which holds the top plate above the sandwich, cooking the top by radiant heat rather than contact (the bottom still by contact).

Copper-look bush on hinge

The whole thing is sturdily built, and finished in a nice brushed stainless steel look, with black for the handle, underside and the few plastic components. The U-shaped bar to which the handle is affixed looks to be diecast.

The mechanism for setting the press position is about as simple as you can get. On the right hand arm of the press is a sliding block made of a dense plastic. In the rear position it rests on a small protrusion from the base, holding up the press lid for open sandwich melt operation. Moved to the most forward position it will, if the press is closed, slide under another protrusion to lock the top and bottom sections together so that the whole unit can be conveniently stowed in an upright position.

It’s in the middle position that the “crush control” stuff comes into operation. In that position the block engages with nothing so the top element can rest on the sandwich. I’d somehow gathered the impression from the press release that the “crush control” force on the sandwich is adjustable. But it never said that. In fact this force is fixed, and it acts to offset some proportion of the weight of the upper section, reducing it to Breville’s claimed 425 grams.

Three position settings

I didn’t check the force but it seemed about right, and certainly seemed considerably less than what the top plate must have weighed. The unit’s box mentioned the use of a counterweight to offset the force, but it’s hard to see how that could be done mechanically. I’m inclined to think the hinge incorporates some kind of spring mechanism. However it does it, the job is done without excess bulk, just copper-look bushes at the hinges to suggest something different is happening there.

It suffers the same weakness that just about all of these kinds of presses seem to share: plate alignment. Because there’s a single hinge, the higher the top plate is above the bottom, the further it is towards the rear. Put in a very tall sandwich and you might be lucky to get the plate to cover both front and back at the top. Addressing this, though, would require considerably more complicated hinge designs.

The bottom plate has a lip to contain things if there should be a spill of melted cheese or whatnot.

Performance

Operation couldn’t be simpler. Plug it in, switch on the power (the unit has its own power switch) and wait until the green light comes on, indicating that cooking temperature has been achieved.

I loaded up the unit over several days with sandwiches with a variety of fillings, generally using the thicker Helga’s bread that can be problematic in a regular sandwich toaster. Despite lashings of cheese, there was never a single overflow.